|
(First, I must say to Amy Chua and her family members: I apologize for passing judgment and making comments on your family’s private affairs
in public – outsiders should not pass judgment and comment on how others raise and teach their children in a manner that those children can
hear or read about it. I feel bad, but it can’t be helped in your case, because the Mom in your family has published this book about your family’s
private affairs, a book that has shaken the world and is affecting the whole of humanity. Therefore, many people in this world now have an
obligation to take a position on many things in this book and that means publicly passing judgment and commenting on how the Mom in your family
raises and teaches her children.)
|
(首先,我要先對蔡美兒及她的家人說,很抱歉,要公開對你們的家事說三道四,指手畫腳。本來外人不應該在別人子女可能聽到或看到的情況下評論別人怎樣教養子女的,我也覺得很難過,
但沒辦法,你們家的媽媽出版了這本震動全球的、關於你們家事的書,對全人類都有影響,所以世界上很多人現在都有責任和義務對這本書里的很多東西表明立場,亦即是公開評論你們家的媽媽怎樣教養子女了。)
|
|
In the book “The Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother” written by Amy Chua,
which, according to the Wall Street Journal, supposedly represents
“Why Chinese Mothers are Superior”, Amy Chua does not respect her daughter’s basic personal dignity, and in turn also allows the daughter to
disrespect mother. This is completely opposite to what traditional Chinese thought advocates for bringing up children.
|
被華爾街日報稱為代表“為什麼中華母親比較優越”的蔡美兒著的
"虎媽媽的戰歌”一書里,蔡美兒既不尊敬女兒的基本人身尊嚴,也反過來縱容女兒對媽媽的不尊敬。
這完全跟中華教養孩子的傳統思想背道而馳。
|
|
In Chapter 11 of the book, Amy Chua describes how, when her second daughter Lulu is seven and has been unable, despite practicing on the piano many hours
a day for many days, to play a certain difficult tune well, Amy Chua condemns her daughter severely. Ms. Chua accuses her daughter of “purposely working
herself into a frenzy”, and of being “lazy, cowardly, self-indulgent, and pathetic”, and threatens her with no meals, no Christmas presents or birthday
parties for 3, 4 years, etc. This kind of insulting condemnation and threat with punishment shows complete disrespect for the daughter’s basic personal
dignify: she is only a seven-year-old who temporarily cannot attain a certain level of skill in piano; she actually has practiced for hours every day;
she has not committed any serious trespasses, nor has she committed any crimes against humanity!
|
書中第11章蔡美兒描述二女Lulu七歲時彈鋼琴儘管練習了好多天,每天彈了好多小時,但是還不能把一首難彈的歌曲彈得夠好,便破口把女兒辱罵和威脅,說她“故意刺激自己以致進入狂亂狀態”、
說她“懶惰、懦弱、自我放縱、是個完全沒用的人”,更威脅女兒,要罰她沒飯吃、三四年都不許拿聖誕禮物或開生日派對等。這種辱罵和威脅,完全不尊重女兒基本的人身尊嚴,她畢竟只是個能力暫時不能
達到琴藝某水平的七歲小孩,她畢竟天天都做了長達數小時的練習,她並沒有做過大逆不道的事,更沒有做過任何傷天害理的事情啊!
|
|
In turn, having received treatment that disrespects her personal dignity over and over, the daughter gradually begins to hit back. It starts with contradicting
mother, and then evolves into returning the insulting rebukes, into shows of complete disrespect for mother. Perversely, this kind of behavior, which is
considered a severe trespass in Chinese culture, Amy Chua does not stop at all, but instead tolerates and allows to go on, and even seems to take pride in her
daughter displaying such behavior.
|
女兒多次承受了這種不尊敬人身尊嚴的對待後,很自然地漸漸開始反抗了,最先是對媽媽反駁,然後演變為反罵。變為對媽媽完全不尊敬時,蔡美兒反而對這種中華文化認為是大逆不道的行為完全不禁止,
反而長期縱容,甚至好像是引以為榮。
|
|
In page 48 of the book, while describing how the second daughter resists the severe music practice schedule, Amy Chua says that she and her daughter form a
pair who are “simultaneously incompatible and inextricably bound”. Then Ms. Chua rather proudly recounts how, in talking with her seven-year-old daughter,
they conclude that they are “good buddies” in a “weird, terrible way”, and then daughter hugs mother. This lets us understand the real picture: Amy Chua,
like so many parents who lack knowledge of the Chinese intellectual heritage, thinks that no matter how disrespectful of the offspring a parent is, as long
as the parent lets the offspring also in turn show disrespect for the parent, then the parent has not mistreated the offspring!
|
書中第48頁講述二女小時怎樣反抗嚴厲的練琴日程時蔡美兒就說,她母女倆是同時水火不容但又不能分離的一對,然後很自豪地描繪一次跟七歲的二女談話時所得出的結論:她們倆是一對“很怪異、很壞很可怕”
的“好朋友”,而女兒說完就擁抱了媽媽。這就讓我們明白真相了:蔡美兒原來好像很多對中華思維傳統缺乏認識的父母一樣,以為無論父母對子女怎樣不尊敬,只要讓子女反過來也對父母不尊敬,便沒有虧待子女了!
|
Sigh! Respect for one’s parents is actually the most basic form of respect for others, and for Amy Chua to not infuse that most basic form of respect for others
into her offspring is actually considered by Chinese culture to be one of the greatest mistreatments by parents of their offspring! It is “to raise but not teach”.
|
唉,對父母的尊敬其實就是最基本的對他人的尊敬,而蔡美兒這樣不把最基本的對他人的尊敬灌輸給子女,其實就是中華文化里父母最虧待子女的行為之一啊!這叫做“養而不教”。
|
|
Of course, according to traditional Chinese culture, offspring may express differing opinions to their parents, since offspring should be able to discuss
anything and everything with their parents, and also, after all, offspring have the duty to dissuade and dispute parents when they are morally wrong, but
the opinions must be expressed in a respectful manner, with politeness and courtesy.
|
當然,根據中華傳統文化,子女可以對父母提出不同意見(凡事有商量嘛,而且,子女對父母有“諫爭”的義務和責任啊),但是,提出時要對父母尊敬、有禮貌。
|
|
In the name of some kind of “achievement”, and in this case it is the playing of musical instruments, to both disrespect the children and then also allow
the children in turn to disrespect their parents, even to the point of loud argument and throwing things in public, can such farces represent the fine
Chinese tradition of bringing up children? Absolutely not. And not only for the Chinese tradition – such farces cannot represent the tradition of any
civilization for bringing up children.
|
父母為了某種“成績”(在蔡美兒來說是為了琴藝)而既不尊敬子女,也縱容子女反過來對父母不敬,甚至在公眾場所里大吵大鬧和擲東西,這種醜劇,能夠代表中華教養子女的優秀傳統嗎?絕對不能!而且,
不光是中華傳統,什麼文明的教養子女傳統都不能代表。
|
|
The Chinese tradition for bringing up children puts the greatest emphasis on respect, and first and foremost on respect for parents. Why is respect for
parents so important? Long ago Confucius has answered this question: it is because those who respect their parents won’t disrespect others (see
The Classic of Xiao, p. 5, Chapter 2, “The Son of Heaven”)! And in the Chinese intellectual
tradition, respect for others is the guarantee of civil society. This is because traditional Chinese culture advocates using Li or courtesy and etiquette
to bring harmony and order to society, and what is the essence of this Li or courtesy and etiquette? It is respect, nothing more. Confucius has said,
“Li – it is nothing other than respect.” (See The Classic of Xiao, p. 25, Chapter 12, “A Broad and Crucial Doctrine”.) Therefore, in the Chinese intellectual
heritage, respect for parents is the fundamental foundation of civil society.
|
中華教養子女的傳統,最注重尊敬,而首要的就是尊敬父母。為什麼尊敬父母這麼重要呢?對此,孔子早就說出了答案,是因為尊敬父母的人不會不尊敬他人(“敬親者不敢慢於人”
《孝經》第5頁第二章“天子”)。
而中華思維傳統里,尊敬他人就是文明社會的保障。這是因為中華思維傳統主張使用禮,來為社會帶來和諧和秩序,而這個禮的本質是什麼呢?只不過是尊敬。孔子說,“禮者,敬而已矣”(《孝經》第25頁第十二章
“廣要道”)。所以,對中華思維傳統來說,尊敬父母是文明社會的根本基礎。
|
|
Therefore, to raise children according to the Chinese intellectual heritage, the parents must set an example by showing respect for the personal dignity of
the children, and at the same time, must firmly uphold the requirement that the children show respect for, and courtesy and politeness to, their parents.
Parents must strictly prohibit all words and acts that show disrespect and must absolutely not tolerate them.
|
所以,要依照中華思維傳統來撫育子女,父母一定要以身作則,尊敬子女的人身尊嚴,同時也一定要堅持規矩,嚴格要求子女對父母尊敬、有禮貌,嚴厲禁止一切不敬的言行,對之絕不能縱容。
|